Hogan Thompson Schuelke Wins Oklahoma Appellate Victory for Mewbourne Oil Company in Top Lease Dispute
Energy litigation firm Hogan Thompson Schuelke recently secured a significant appellate victory for Mewbourne Oil Company in a top lease dispute in Dewey County, Oklahoma.
After discovering that Mewbourne planned to drill valuable multi-unit horizontal wells, Yukon Trading Company obtained competing top leases from several lessors of the property and claimed that Mewbourne’s leases terminated and that the top leases were in effect. As a result, Yukon claimed a significant portion of Mewbourne’s interest in the new wells belonged to them. After the parties moved for summary judgment, the trial court ruled in favor of Mewbourne.
Yukon appealed, and in September 2026, the Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals affirmed the summary judgment in full. The appellate court became one of the first in the country to apply the Oklahoma Supreme Court’s Tres C, LLC v. Raker Resources framework to lease terminations involving cessation of production, affirming that Mewbourne commenced drilling within the contractual window.
Because termination claims can determine ownership of valuable oil and gas properties worth tens or even hundreds of millions of dollars, this ruling provides helpful guidance on lease preservation and protects operators against predatory top leasing across valuable horizontal development units.
The Hogan Thompson Schuelke trial and appellate team included Chris Hogan, Samantha Thompson, and Cody Rutowski, in addition to local counsel Stephen Beam.
If you are dealing with a complex oil and gas title dispute, contact us to discuss how our trial team can assist in protecting your interests.